I just read that there’s a remake in the works of The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance and it’s going to be updated to 1980s urban America. The source is reliable so the news comes as no small surprise. Having covered the making of this classic pretty thoroughly in Lee Marvin Point Blank, naturally through the prism of Lee Marvin’s participation in it ( at least I think I did), there’s very little to add about that other than my opinion of this upcoming remake.
Then again, there may be a few tidbits left, such as this quote from Rolling Stone magazine in which Marvin talks about the film’s legendary director: “John Ford. Fucking Ford. You’ll never see skillets and steaks like that in anybody else’s picture. He’s like Dickens. It’s all larger than life. That’s what the old guys understood about movies. If its not bigger than life, put it on television.”
Or, Marvin’s opinion of the film’s leading actor, John Wayne: “Now there is a legend. I liked him. But films were his whole life. I tried not to let that happen to me. I’ve never had any desire to die in the saddle.”
That all said, the obvious question becomes why in the Wide World of Sports would Paramount want to remake this classic western? Yeah, the easy answer is always money but if that’s the case why remove the element that made the film so enigmatic and get listed on the National Registry? Film critic Gene Siskel used to expound on how classic films shouldn’t be remade but bad ones should so they can improved. I partially agree with him but who want to make a bad film? There’s no money in it. It is possible that the remake could open the original up to a new audience of younger viewers but successful DVD sales have already done that.
So the question still resonates: WHY???? Is contemporary Hollywood so bereft of originality they have to remake EVERYTHING?? Pretty disheartening thought, I know, but here’s an idea. If any Hollywood producer, director, actor, or screenwriter is genuinely interested in a terrific property worthy of screen adapation, contact ME here or my agent, Mike Hamilburg. You’ll be pleasantly surprised to discover what a worthy project Lee Marvin Point Blank would be on the big screen. After all, like the man said, if it’s not larger than life, put it on televsion.